laliberty:
I’ve brought up my disappointment with the persistent unseriousness of some of the posts promoted to the politics tag (see here, here, and here). (I also implored the other editors to “like” or “reblog” a post before or after promoting it in order to maintain transparency in the process - and maybe keep editors accountable for what they promote.)
Well, fellow editor Ryking, in addition to reigniting his obsession with slinging puerile insults in my direction, has lately been expressing disappointment as well, going so far as to petition his followers to demand Tumblr management remove whom he inaccurately calls “right-wing editors” from their posts…
I’ve snipped your latest performance of Argumentum Verbosium theater; if others wish to sped eons reading your ponderous TL;DR drek, they’re free to go to the source. I’ll just jump right into rebutting your nonsense.
1) I’m not the one with the obsession here, as evidenced by the many hours you spend writing War and Peace-length posts like the one above to attack me.
2) I agree some (but only three or four at most) of the examples you cited didn’t merit inclusion in the tag as they mocked a candidate’s appearance (McConnell and turtles, Bachmann’s crazy eyes, et. al), but otherwise the posts you complain about offer excellent critiques of right-wing ideology, underscore examples of right-wing hypocrisy, debunk right-wing lies, or otherwise offer some topical middlebrow humor. I make no apologies for occasionally promoting something whimsical.
3) The right-wing posts I — and others — have shredded — have been filled with blatant falsehoods. If you right-wing editors are going to promote your ideology with lies, expect to be called out when doing so.
4) When I say there is a lack of diversity, I mean in two ways (and I also speak for Republican bloggers who don’t wish to named).
First, every right-wing editor is a libertarian save Holzbach, who is a pro-Paul Republican. This concerns other Republican Tumblr users who feel mainstream, pro-GOP conservatism isn’t being represented. They also complain that you right-wing editors aren’t promoting many right-wing posts to the Politics section and believe that they could do the job better.
Second, the majority of right-wing posts that do get promoted by you right-wing editors tend to come from the same small clique: Evil Teabagger, Liberty Idaho, Conservative Brew, and Communism Kills. While I find these low-quality posts laughably bad and easily debunked, others on your side of the aisle are resentful that “bottom of the barrel” conservatives are regularly featured. They feel that right-wing ideology is being given a bad rap on Tumblr because better posts from better writers aren’t being selected.
5) If you don’t like being insulted, then stop hurling insults at others. Or stop hypocritically complaining about it. But I guess asking you to stop being a hypocrite is like asking you to stop breathing.