[A] young man — a student at Windham High School, I think — asked a question that began, “Islam is trying to take over this country.”
The questioner went on for a while, noting that he was a Christian and wanted his rights protected against Islam. The crowd applauded.
Gingrich didn’t quite endorse the question, but he certainly didn’t correct it: There was no caveat that most American Muslims are good citizens, or that Constitutional rights apply to all religions. Instead Gingrich pivoted directly into a riff about the dual threats, to Christians and Jews, of Sharia law and of secularism.
The moment captured Gingrich’s political skills: He offers parts of the Republican base who are used to being dismissed and marginalized by the mainstream media — for what was, in this particular case, an actual fringe conspiracy theory, or at best a wild overstatement — a sense of legitimacy and intellectual heft, a sense that their concerns are part of a profound, deep, and fundamental structural concern.
But pandering to your audience when they are peddling crazy theories isn’t actually good general election politics, and it may not be good primary politics. You wind up owning the fringe.